Beautycounter just dropped a $27 clean mascara that’s longwear and smudge-proof, and I tried it

Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the products and deals we love. If you love them too and decide to purchase through the links below, we may receive a commission. Pricing and availability are subject to change. 

Although it seems like everyone and their mama has lash extensions these days, there are still a few of us rocking with our naturals. And yes, that means mascara is a must when you want that extra length and volume.

Truth be told, I love the way lash extensions look, but I don’t have the time or money to commit. Plus, there’s a part of me that’s secretly terrified they’ll make my actual lashes fall out.

As a result, I’m continuously on the hunt for the latest, greatest mascara. You know, the one that will make your eyes look wider and brighter because it hugs your lashes just right and makes them extra-long and fluffy. Though they may seem elusive, there are actually quite a few top-notch mascaras out there that rival falsies.

Most recently, my mascara quest led me to Beautycounter’s newest launch, the Think Big All-in-One Mascara. It’s a $27 formula that promises to not only help “lashes appear longer, fuller and stronger” but also to be longwear and smudge-proof. Oh, and it doesn’t have any harmful ingredients. Pretty high bar, right? That’s why I just had to put it to the test for myself.

Think Big All-in-One Mascara, $27

Credit: Beautycounter

I got my hands on the Beautycounter Think Big mascara, thanks to the folks at the brand, and immediately swiped one coat onto my lashes. It instantly made my lashes more defined and fuller. Full disclosure, that’s not really all that difficult because my eyelashes are super thin and fine. But still, I was really impressed after just a few swipes. You can see the difference just a first pass makes in the photo below.

Credit: Jeanine Edwards

Impressive, right? My lashes looked pretty good without much effort at all, and that was exciting. I decided to continue the test by wearing the Beautycounter Think Big mascara for a full day.

After 10 hours, I’m happy to report the Beautycounter Think Big mascara is legit. Not only did it keep my lashes looking longer and defined for the full day, but it didn’t do that thing where it deposits black stuff in the creases under my eye. That is major in my book. So many mascaras leave me looking like I’ve been in a fight at the end of the day.

I can be a penny-pincher, so I will readily admit that $27 is pricey for a mascara. That said, I really like that this one has a clean formula, the wand is amazing when it comes to gripping even my super fine eyelashes and the formula really does hold up all day long. If you’re going to splurge on a mascara, this one is definitely worthy.

To stay up to date on the latest beauty trends, popular products and must-shop sales, subscribe to our Beauty newsletter here.

Want to stay in the know on all things beauty? Watch In The Know Live: Beauty every Monday at 1 p.m. EST/10 a.m. PST to discover the best products and latest trends.

If you liked this post, check out FaceGym’s new skin care products.

More from In The Know:

4 under-the-radar Bath & Body Works scents that actually smell so good

I tried Beautycounter’s new brightening hand serum that doubles as a sanitizer — here’s what you need to know

People can’t get enough of maude’s wellness products: ‘Absolutely love and highly recommend’

If puffiness is a problem for you, try this top-rated Amazon fix: ‘The best product of its kind’