Which athlete allegedly left Tana Mongeau for a Kardashian? Her story time explained

Tana Mongeau, the controversial YouTuber who is notorious for spilling secrets about her life in wide-ranging videos, has her fans scrambling to figure out the identity of a mystery man in her latest story time.

“This video is about to get me in so much trouble,” she said within the first 10 seconds of her latest post. “My entire life is an embarrassment.”

What was Tana Mongeau’s latest story time about?

In the video titled “I CHOSE JAKE PAUL OVER AN ATHLETE & HE LEFT ME FOR A KARDASHIAN: STORYTIME,” Mongeau claimed that in April 2019, she was “talking” to both Jake Paul and an unnamed athlete.

“He’s genuinely one of the nicest people I’ve ever talked to in my life,” she said about the athlete before further praising his charm and talent.

She said she interpreted something the athlete said to her as a “sign” she needed to choose to be with Paul over him, so she ghosted the athlete and went to Paul’s house, though the athlete invited her to go on vacation with him.

The next day, she woke up and felt bad for ghosting him, but before she could make things right, fans had figured out that she had posted a selfie to Snapchat in Paul’s bed thanks to the distinctive pattern on his headboard.

That realization went viral โ€” and the athlete took note. He told her, essentially, that they are going to be good friends, thus ending the relationship.

Just a day later, Mongeau claimed that the athlete returned to L.A. from his vacation, picked up another woman and took her back on vacation. That woman happened to be a member of the Kardashian family.

She also mentioned that she found out about the whole thing via the Daily Mail.

“I get it, it’s karma for being a dumb, dumb b****,” Mongeau said, before clarifying that this was the beginning of her road to “becoming a Paul” and marrying Jake.

“Don’t act like I wasn’t thinking about this athlete walking down the aisle,” she added.

Who is the mystery athlete in Mongeau’s story time video?

It seemed to be a no-brainer that the Kardashian involved was probably Kendall Jenner, who’s close to Mongeau’s age and wasn’t in a long-term relationship at the time.

One fan pointed out that Kyle Kuzma and Jenner were spotted vacationing together around that same time frame in 2019.

Mongeau said she doesn’t follow the athlete on social media anymore, though, and she does follow Kuzma.

Another suggested that it might be Ben Simmons because Jenner had been linked to him “on and off” for the entire year.

News of Simmons and Jenner vacationing never made it to the Daily Mail, though.

Multiple fans seem to think Devin Booker checks all the boxes, though, as he was seen picking up Jenner at the airport in April and May of 2019.

It seems Mongeau wants to protect her mystery man’s identity so it’s not likely that she’ll make a statement confirming who it is, but the internet always seems to find a way.

In The Know is now available on Apple News โ€” follow us here!  

If you enjoyed this article, read more about Mongeau’s last explosive story time video.

More from In The Know:

Who is Alejandro Rosario? People think he’s dating beauty guru Nikita Dragun

7 beauty products this beauty editor absolutely loved in October

Who is Ava Louise? The influencer found fame by licking a toilet seat

Shop our favorite beauty products from In The Know Beauty on TikTok

Listen to the latest episode of our pop culture podcast, We Should Talk: