On July 25, one of the girls uploaded a video showing off their spookily similar appearances.
In November 2018, Reagan reached out to Avery on Instagram after learning of her existence. In the message, she admitted that they “literally look exactly the same.”
“Hahah we do look alike,” Avery agreed.
Similar facial features aren’t the only thing the girls have in common, though. As Reagan and Avery quickly realized after exchanging a few messages, they also share a birthday.
Though the girls were born one year apart, many TikTok users are convinced that they’re actually long-lost twins.
“Someone got the year wrong on their birth certificate. Y’all are twins,” one person said.
“This lowkey freaked me out,” another user commented.
“Y’all have the same bday, this is not a coincidence,” a third user added.
According to the video, Reagan and Avery “still talk” and “wish each other [a] happy birthday.”
If you enjoyed this story, check out this woman that almost looks too much like Ryan Reynolds.
More from In The Know: