I took my boyfriend on a romantic getaway to Mexico — these were my 6 best looks

Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the products and deals we love. If you love them too and decide to purchase through the links below, we may receive a commission. Pricing and availability are subject to change.

My boyfriend and I have been together for the better part of eight years and had never been on a real, romantic getaway. The timing was ideal: He had just finished up his first year of law school with all of his hair intact (barely) and needed the break, and I just really, really, really wanted to go.

After finding a dope last-minute package in my budget, I surprised him with an all-inclusive beach vacation to the Excellence Playa Mujeres in Mexico, just outside Cancún. But because we were only staying for five days and four nights, I knew I had to pack my vacation outfits strategically.

Credit: Sarah Weldon

Since half of my suitcase was going to be filled with an unreal amount of sunscreen, and I was determined to avoid extra baggage fees, there were two conditions for everything I packed. Each piece had to work with at least two outfits, and I had to love every inch of fabric. I even limited myself to just two pairs of shoes (excluding sneakers for travel days) and two bags.

Surprisingly, it was a success. While I was fully obsessed with every item I brought — including this $35 Amazon slip dress, a dainty floral bikini top and the best terrycloth cover-up — a few looks stood out above the rest. Scroll below to shop the best vacation outfits I wore to Cancún.

Outfit #1: Announcing Our Arrival

Credit: Sarah Weldon

When it comes to vacation outfits, I firmly believe the first bikini you wear will set the tone for the entire vacation. I opted for this bright, vibrant green number that basically screamed “WE HAVE ARRIVED!” to the entire property. With my waterproof Birkenstock sandals and colorful oversized button-up, this first look was an obvious choice.

Shop the Look:

Oversized Colorblock Poplin Button-Up Shirt, $45.50 (Orig. $60)

Credit: Abercrombie & Fitch

Always Fits Scoop Neck Bikini Top, $24.75-$55.00 (Orig. $55)

Credit: Nordstrom

Always Fits Good Waist Bikini Bottoms, $18.97-$49 (Orig. $49)

Credit: Nordstrom

Birkenstock Arizona EVA Sandals, $50

Credit: Free People

Leia 49-Millimeter Cat Eye Sunglasses, $39.97 (Orig. $150)

Credit: Nordstrom Rack

Outfit #2: Dressing Up for the Fanciest Dinner

Credit: Sarah Weldon

The thrill of getting dressed up for dinner on vacation after you’ve been in the sun and ocean all day is unparalleled. For our second night, we decided to hit up the fanciest restaurant on the property for only one reason: I was dying to pull out this Hill House number from this year’s Nap Dress Summer collection.

Shop the look:

The Isabella Top, $95

Credit: Hill House Home

The Mirabel Skirt, $125

Credit: Hill House Home

Emilia Pleated Knot Mule, $227.99 (Orig. $350)

Credit: Zappos

Croissant Dôme Hoops, $78

Credit: Mejuri

OUTFIT #3: Claiming Our Beach Spot

Credit: Sarah Weldon

Before heading to the beach every day, my boyfriend and I would do the whole resort song-and-dance and plop our towels and books down by 7:30 a.m. to claim our favorite chairs. It might not be fair, but such is life. Anyways, once we had the ideal spot on the beach, we hardly left — including for lunch.

Although it wasn’t the plan, this blue bikini from Monday Swimwear with my brand-new straw hat matched perfectly with the individual pizzas we had every day. And, of course, no vacation is complete without a woven tote, and this $26 Amazon find changed the beach bag game.

Shop the Look:

Copacabana Top, $80

Credit: Monday Swimwear

Seychelles Bottom, $79

Credit: Monday Swimwear

Wide Brim Packable Straw Hat, $59.50

Credit: J.Crew

Oversized Poplin Button-Up Shirt, $45 (Orig. $60)

Credit: Abercrombie & Fitch

Poplin Pull-On Shorts, $24.74 (Orig. $45)

Credit: Abercrombie & Fitch

Straw Bag for Women, $26.99

Outfit #4: Becoming a Prune in the Pool

Credit: Sarah Weldon

Please excuse the terribly blurry elevator mirror selfie! My phone camera was smeared with sunscreen, and I simply needed to send a picture of my sea-creature bucket hat to my best friend ASAP. While I adore my new sea creature bucket hat and the very loud button-down, I was craving an all-black moment.

For a true secret outfit reveal, I decided to pull out an ultra-flattering high-waisted black bikini with my favorite black cat-eye sunglasses from the Adam Selman x Le Specs collab. After all, I am a born-and-raised New Yorker, and the cliché is real.

The Sun Hat, $60

Credit: Hill House Home

Maui Top, $94

Credit: Monday Swimwear

Riviera Bottom, $82

Credit: Monday Swimwear

Le Specs – The Last Lolita Sunglasses, $59.50

Credit: Amazon

Relaxed Mid-Length Denim Shorts, $69.99 (Orig. $78)

Credit: Madewell

Outfit #5: Going for a Golden Hour Stroll

Credit: Sarah Weldon

When I think of vacation, I think of the golden hour. The way the sunlight reflects on the water right before the sky turns pink and orange is the ultimate romantic lighting. I bought this cropped sweater tank from Madewell specifically for this casual (but still put together) moment. Paired with this light green floral skirt, this was a peak vacation outfit out of all the vacation outfits.

Surprisingly, the entire look was lightweight. The wool of the top and the double-layered skirt didn’t bother me as I lived out my favorite rom-com dreams with my boyfriend while we waited for our dinner reservation. Plus, the soft wind is a nice touch for a shameless photoshoot.

Shop the Look:

Halstead Square Neck Sweater Tank, $48

Credit: Nordstrom

Dipped Waist Midi Skirt, $52.50 (Orig. $70)

Credit: Abercrombie & Fitch

Outfit #6: Heading Home

Credit: Sarah Weldon/Sesame Workshop/HBO

What’s a roundup of romantic getaway vacation outfits if you don’t include airport looks? Yes, I did throw a full-on little green monster fit when we left. The one thing that kept me from whining like a toddler the entire four-hour flight home was my all-green outfit — even though I looked like Oscar the Grouch with a tan. Go ahead, spot the difference.

Shop the Look:

Daybreak Sneaker, $90

Credit: NIKE

Luka Duffel, $120

Credit: CALPAK

Luka Belt Bag, $58

Credit: CALPAK

Lennix Plisse Set, $83

Credit: Princess Polly

The Bigger Carry-On, $295

Credit: Away

If you liked this story, shop these editor-approved picks from Nordstrom.

More from In The Know:

Listen to the latest episode of our pop culture podcast, We Should Talk: