Personalized Valentine’s Day gifts they’ll love

Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the products and deals we love. If you love them too and decide to purchase through the links below, we may receive a commission. Pricing and availability are subject to change. 

Melanie Sutrathada is an In The Know lifestyle contributor. Follow her on Instagram and Twitter for more.

The countdown to Valentine’s Day is on, but that doesn’t mean you can’t still find a thoughtful gift that goes beyond chocolates and flowers. While there’s nothing wrong with either, there’s something so exciting and thoughtful about a personalized gift, whether you’re shopping for a romantic partner or a Galentine!

Here are some of our favorite custom gifts they’re sure to love:

Custom Converse Chuck Taylor All Star, $95

Credit: Converse

From leopard print laces and custom colors like “Love” or “Lips” to initials on the heel stripe, there are tons of ways to make these sneakers extra special for that special person in your life.

Artifact Uprising Color Series Photo Book, starting at $22

Credit: Artifact Uprising

Reminisce on your very own love story with snapshots of your favorite memories together all in one unique gift they’ll keep forever. You can even pick gorgeous foil lettering and colorful covers that bring every story to life.

Kendra Scott Allison Delicate Bracelet in 18k Yellow Gold Vermeil, $145

Credit: Kendra Scott

Meet the delicate bracelet they’ll never want to take off. Engrave both of your initials, their name or maybe even the coordinates of where you got married on this simple bar pendent and you’ll definitely win the gifting game this Valentine’s Day.

Custom Personalized Star Map Date Square Print, $6

Credit: Amazon

Show you care with a thoughtful gift that they’ll be able to look at every day. You can customize this personalized star map to show the stars on any night (like when you had your first kiss or got engaged) and gives me major Walk to Remember vibes. This would definitely be Jamie-approved.

Uncommon Goods Personalized Bourbon Barrel Flight with Glasses, $75

Credit: Uncommon Goods

Wow your Galentine with a gorgeous customized reclaimed bourbon barrel flight. It will definitely become a point of conversation every time you sit down together to enjoy your favorite spirit.

Papier Full of Heart Notebook, $26.99

Credit: Papier

Show your love for your bestie or special someone with a customizable notebook for journaling their thoughts, writing love songs or anything else they can dream of. Personalize the cover with their name, initials, nickname or — my favorite — a cute little inside joke that only they would get. 

CaitlynMinimalist Custom Handwriting Bracelet, $29.60

Credit: Etsy

This bracelet will forever be one that makes my list for great personalized gifts because of its sentimental value and affordability. As someone who has shopped from this seller on Etsy quite often, I can tell you from firsthand experience that this gift will be a hit.

Madewell The Zip-Top Transport Crossbody, $158

Credit: Madewell

Skip the basic presents this year and show your love with a gorgeous leather carryall that you can customize with initials and interchangeable bag straps.

Mark & Graham Waffle Knit Spa Robe, $119 (Orig. $139)

Credit: Mark & Graham

Sometimes, all you need is a luxurious robe, and this custom embroidered one does not disappoint. It’s made from sustainably sourced Turkish cotton and is sure to become a staple.

Courant Catch:3 Classic Accessory Tray, $140 (Orig. $175)

Credit: Courant

This plugless charging pad and accessory tray is perfect for their nightstand. It’s a great gift for the person who already has everything. The monogramming goes up to 20 characters, so you can really personalize this leather beauty with a date, quote or whatever your heart desires.

SENIA Aphrodite Halo Ring, $290

Credit: SENIA

Obsessed doesn’t even begin to describe how I feel about this ring. This gorgeous piece is adorned in hand-cut pink topaz gemstones and named after Aphrodite, the goddess of love. Roman numerals and customizable engraving allow for the perfect gift to commemorate any special date.

Positive Prints Where We Met Map, $44

Credit: Positive Prints

Add a personal touch to your Valentine’s Day gift this year with a special map of where you met. It’s so sentimental and sweet that they’ll want to hang it up right away.

MirageLeather Leather Dopp Kit, starting at $24.90 (Orig. starting at $49.80)

Credit: Etsy

If your bae loves to travel, this leather dopp kit will be something they reach for again and again. These bags are the perfect Valentine’s gift with a personal touch – you can monogram them with your sweetie’s initials.

Mimeo Photos Personalized Photo Puzzle, starting at $19.99

Credit: Mimeo

Put love in every piece of your gift this year. Puzzles ended up having a resurgence in the past few years, and what better way to make them more meaningful than to create a custom one just for you and your loved one?

If you enjoyed this story, check out these beauty products that will make you nostalgic for the ’90s!

Listen to the latest episode of our pop culture podcast, We Should Talk: